In this guide
"What's my ideal weight?" is one of the most typed questions in health, and one of the most quietly misleading. It sounds like there's a single right answer, handed down by science, that you can look up by height. Type your height into five different websites and you'll get five different "ideal" weights, each stated with total confidence. Try again for a woman of 160 cm and the answers might range over five kilograms.
The disagreement isn't a sign that the websites are sloppy. It's a sign that the question is built on formulas that were never meant to answer it. We went back to where the four classic ideal-weight formulas came from, compared them against healthy-range methods, and built a chart in kilograms and pounds, including the lower upper-limit that applies to many Asian adults. We'll also show how to turn all this into a goal you can actually work toward.
The short version: the four classic "ideal body weight" formulas (Hamwi, Devine, Robinson, Miller) were created for drug dosing and diabetic diet planning, not as personal health targets, and for the same person they can differ by about 5 kg. A healthier approach is a weight range for your height, based on a BMI of 18.5–24.9 (or 18.5–22.9 for South and East Asian adults under WHO and NICE guidance), checked against your waist-to-height ratio. For a 170 cm man, that's about 53–72 kg (53–66 kg on the Asian range), not a single "ideal" number.
The Question Everyone Types, and the Trouble With It
The phrase "ideal weight" implies a single optimum: a number you could hit and stay at, perfectly healthy. Bodies don't work like that. Health outcomes vary smoothly across a wide band of weights, and the "best" weight for you depends on your muscle, your frame, where you carry fat, your age and your health history. A single number gives false precision. A range, plus a couple of other checks, gives you something honest.
The Four Classic Formulas
These formulas are still built into many calculators. They apply to adults taller than 5 feet (152.4 cm), with "per inch" meaning each inch over 5 feet.
| Formula | Men | Women | Year and original purpose |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hamwi | 106 lb + 6 lb per inch | 100 lb + 5 lb per inch | 1964; developed for diabetic diet planning |
| Devine | 50 kg + 2.3 kg per inch | 45.5 kg + 2.3 kg per inch | 1974; created for drug dosing (the antibiotic gentamicin) |
| Robinson | 52 kg + 1.9 kg per inch | 49 kg + 1.7 kg per inch | 1983; proposed as a revision for clinical dosing |
| Miller | 56.2 kg + 1.41 kg per inch | 53.1 kg + 1.36 kg per inch | 1983; another dosing-oriented revision |
Same Person, Four Answers
Here's what each formula says for a 170 cm man (about 6.9 inches over 5 feet) and a 160 cm woman (about 3.0 inches over 5 feet), alongside the healthy range from BMI:
| Method | Man, 170 cm | Woman, 160 cm |
|---|---|---|
| Hamwi | 67.0 kg | 52.1 kg |
| Devine | 65.9 kg | 52.4 kg |
| Robinson | 65.2 kg | 54.1 kg |
| Miller | 66.0 kg | 57.2 kg |
| Spread of the four | about 2 kg | about 5 kg |
| BMI 18.5–24.9 (standard healthy range) | 53.5–72.0 kg | 47.4–63.7 kg |
| BMI 18.5–22.9 (Asian healthy range) | 53.5–66.2 kg | 47.4–58.6 kg |
The formulas cluster, and notice how narrow they are compared with the width of the healthy range. That's a clue: each is a single point inside a much wider band, and the "correct" point inside the band depends on you.
Where They Came From (and Why That Matters)
None of these four formulas started life as advice on how much you should weigh.
- Hamwi (1964) was a quick rule of thumb used in diet planning for people with diabetes, a clinician's shortcut for setting a target.
- Devine (1974) came from a hospital pharmacist's need to calculate a safe dose of gentamicin. Many drugs are dosed by weight, but fat tissue holds little of them, so pharmacists wanted a "lean" reference weight.
- Robinson and Miller (1983) were published in the American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy as alternative dosing-oriented revisions.
Older "desirable weight" tables, such as the Metropolitan Life Insurance tables of the 1940s to 1980s, were based on the weights of insured people with the lowest mortality, and they shifted upward between editions. They reflected the people an insurer chose to cover, not the whole population.
The point isn't that these formulas are useless. They're useful in a clinic for drug dosing. But using them as your personal health goal is borrowing a number built for a different job.
What the Formulas Ignore
- Muscle and frame. A muscular person and a sedentary person of the same height can both be healthy at very different weights.
- Where you carry fat. Fat around the waist and organs carries more risk than fat on the hips and thighs.
- Ethnicity. Risk rises at lower weights in South and East Asian adults, as we explain in our BMI for South Asians article.
- Age. Healthy targets for older adults can differ.
- Short stature. The formulas extrapolate below 5 feet (152.4 cm), and the results become shaky.
- Health context. Blood sugar, blood pressure and cholesterol often matter more than the scale.
The Better Method: A Healthy Weight Range
The modern approach is to define a healthy range from BMI, then check it with waist measurement. It isn't perfect, but it has a better evidence base. In the Global BMI Mortality Collaboration analysis in The Lancet (2016), which pooled data from over 10 million participants in 239 studies, mortality was lowest at a BMI of about 20 to 25 among people who had never smoked and had no chronic disease, and rose steadily above that. For South and East Asian adults, risk rises earlier, which is why the WHO and NICE use lower upper limits (23 for increased risk and 27.5 for high risk).
Healthy weight range = BMI × height² (in metres).
Standard range: 18.5 to 24.9. Asian range: 18.5 to 22.9.
Example: 1.65 m tall. Height² = 2.7225. Standard range: 50.4 kg to 67.8 kg. Asian range: 50.4 kg to 62.3 kg.
You can run your own numbers in seconds with our ideal weight calculator and BMI calculator.
Healthy Weight Chart by Height: Standard and Asian Ranges
| Height | Standard healthy range (BMI 18.5–24.9) | Asian upper limit (BMI 22.9) |
|---|---|---|
| 150 cm (4′11″) | 41.6–56.0 kg (92–123 lb) | 51.5 kg (114 lb) |
| 155 cm (5′1″) | 44.4–59.8 kg (98–132 lb) | 55.0 kg (121 lb) |
| 160 cm (5′3″) | 47.4–63.7 kg (104–140 lb) | 58.6 kg (129 lb) |
| 165 cm (5′5″) | 50.4–67.8 kg (111–149 lb) | 62.3 kg (137 lb) |
| 170 cm (5′7″) | 53.5–72.0 kg (118–159 lb) | 66.2 kg (146 lb) |
| 175 cm (5′9″) | 56.7–76.3 kg (125–168 lb) | 70.1 kg (155 lb) |
| 180 cm (5′11″) | 59.9–80.7 kg (132–178 lb) | 74.2 kg (164 lb) |
| 185 cm (6′1″) | 63.3–85.2 kg (140–188 lb) | 78.4 kg (173 lb) |
How to read it: the lower end of the range is the same for everyone (BMI 18.5). If you're South Asian, Chinese or from another Asian background, treat the last column as the upper end of your target range, particularly if your waist is above average. Reaching the top of the standard range isn't a health emergency, and being in the middle of it isn't a guarantee, which is why the next check matters.
The Waist Check That Matters More Than the Number
Weight alone can't tell you where fat is. Waist-to-height ratio (waist divided by height) can, and the simple target is to keep your waist below half your height. A person at the top of the "healthy" weight range with a waist above 0.5 may carry more risk than someone a little heavier with a smaller waist. Our Navy-method guide and body fat calculator add another angle, and our article on BMI for South Asians has waist targets for every height.
Special Groups: Athletes, Older Adults, Pregnancy and Teens
| Group | What changes |
|---|---|
| Athletes and very muscular people | BMI-based ranges can label a lean, muscular person "overweight"; use waist-to-height ratio and body-fat estimates instead |
| Older adults | Preserving muscle matters more than hitting a low number; some research suggests slightly higher BMIs may be less risky in later life, so discuss targets with your clinician |
| Pregnancy and breastfeeding | Ideal weight doesn't apply; follow your midwife's guidance on gestational weight gain |
| Children and teenagers | Use age- and sex-specific growth charts from a clinician, not adult formulas |
| People with a history of disordered eating | Fixation on a target number can be harmful; speak to a professional before setting one |
| People with medical conditions | Your clinician's target based on your health markers should take priority |
How to Set a Goal Weight You Can Actually Reach
- Find your healthy range from the chart or the ideal weight calculator.
- Check your waist-to-height ratio. Aim for under 0.5.
- Set a first milestone, not a final number. A 5–10% loss from your current weight produces real metabolic benefits for many people with excess weight. In the large US Diabetes Prevention Program, roughly 7% weight loss plus regular activity cut the progression to type 2 diabetes by about 58%.
- Choose a pace. A common guide is about 0.5–1% of body weight a week, which our calorie-deficit article explains in detail. Use the calorie deficit calculator to turn it into a daily target.
- Protect muscle. Keep protein high (see the protein intake calculator) and lift something.
- Review every 8–12 weeks. If your waist, blood pressure, blood sugar and energy are improving, you may not need to chase the bottom of the range.
- Set a maintenance range, such as ±2 kg, not a single number. A range lets life happen without alarm bells.
The Bottom Line
There's no single "ideal" weight. The four classic formulas were built for drug dosing and diabetic diet planning, they disagree with each other by up to about 5 kg for the same person, and they ignore muscle, waist, age and ethnicity. A healthy range based on BMI, paired with a waist-to-height check, is a more honest answer. For a 170 cm adult that's roughly 53–72 kg, or 53–66 kg if you're from an Asian background where risk rises earlier.
So use the chart as a map, not a target. Find your range, check your waist, aim for a modest first milestone and let your health markers, not just the scale, tell you when you've arrived.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the ideal body weight formula?
There are four classic ones: Hamwi, Devine, Robinson and Miller. The Devine formula (men: 50 kg + 2.3 kg per inch over 5 feet; women: 45.5 kg + 2.3 kg per inch) is the most widely used, but all four were developed for clinical dosing or diet planning, not as personal health targets.
Why do ideal weight calculators give different answers?
Because they use different formulas. For the same woman, the four classic ideal-weight formulas can differ by around 5 kg.
What is a healthy weight range for my height?
Use BMI 18.5–24.9 for most adults, which for 170 cm is about 53.5–72.0 kg. For South and East Asian adults, a BMI of 18.5–22.9 is commonly recommended, about 53.5–66.2 kg at 170 cm.
Is ideal weight the same as healthy weight?
No. "Ideal weight" suggests a single number. A healthy weight is a range, and the right point inside it depends on your muscle, waist, age and health markers.
Should Asians use a lower ideal weight?
The WHO and NICE use lower BMI thresholds for increased risk in Asian populations (23 and 27.5), so many clinicians treat a BMI of 22.9 as the upper end of the healthy range for these groups.
Are ideal weight formulas accurate for short or tall people?
Less so. They were designed for adults taller than 5 feet (152.4 cm), and they extrapolate in a straight line at extreme heights, so they can be unreliable.
How much weight should I aim to lose?
A 5–10% reduction is a meaningful first milestone for many people with excess weight. Aim for a pace of about 0.5–1% of body weight per week and review your waist and health markers, not just the scale.
References & Sources
- Hamwi, G. J. (1964). Therapy: changing dietary concepts. In Danowski, T. S. (ed.), Diabetes Mellitus: Diagnosis and Treatment, Vol. 1. American Diabetes Association.
- Devine, B. J. (1974). Gentamicin therapy. Drug Intelligence and Clinical Pharmacy, 8, 650–655.
- Robinson, J. D., Lupkiewicz, S. M., Palenik, L., Lopez, L. M. & Ariet, M. (1983). Determination of ideal body weight for drug dosage calculations. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy, 40(6), 1016–1019.
- Miller, D. R., Carlson, J. D., Lloyd, B. J. & Day, B. J. (1983). Determining ideal body weight (and mass). American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy, 40(10), 1622–1625.
- Global BMI Mortality Collaboration (2016). Body-mass index and all-cause mortality: individual-participant-data meta-analysis of 239 prospective studies in four continents. The Lancet, 388(10046), 776–786.
- WHO Expert Consultation (2004). Appropriate body-mass index for Asian populations and its implications for policy and intervention strategies. The Lancet, 363(9403), 157–163.
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (2025). Overweight and obesity management (NG246).
- Diabetes Prevention Program Research Group (2002). Reduction in the incidence of type 2 diabetes with lifestyle intervention or metformin. New England Journal of Medicine, 346(6), 393–403.
- MacrosMeasure (2026). Free Ideal Weight Calculator.
- MacrosMeasure (2026). Free BMI Calculator.
Calculate your own numbers — free.
18 science-backed calculators covering everything in this article and more.
