In this guide
Walk through any wellness shop in November and you'll meet bone broth: in glossy cartons, in powders, in jars with a handwritten look. It's marketed as a "protein-packed" winter drink, a collagen source for skin and joints, a gut-soother and a cure for the common cold. Social media loves it. Grandmothers swore by it long before any influencer did.
So is it a smart addition to a protein-conscious winter? The answer is a nuanced "sometimes", and the details matter more than the marketing. We read the laboratory analysis of real broths, the collagen research that wellness brands lean on and the trials comparing collagen with other proteins for muscle. Then we worked out what a cup of broth is genuinely good for, and when you'd do better with something else.
The short version: a cup of bone broth typically provides roughly 6–10 grams of protein for about 40 calories when it's a good product, but published analyses find enormous variation, from under 1 gram to over 10 grams per serving (and far more in some café servings). The protein is largely collagen, which is not a complete protein and is a poor stimulus for muscle building compared with whey, and standard home or commercial broths fall short of the collagen amounts used in supplement trials. It's a warm, hydrating, low-calorie, modest protein top-up, and a lovely winter ritual, but not a muscle-building or joint-fixing powerhouse.
The Wellness-Aisle Hero
Bone broth is made by simmering animal bones, often with vegetables, herbs and a splash of vinegar, for many hours. The long simmer pulls out gelatin (cooked collagen), minerals and flavour. It's deliciously savoury and, when chilled, often sets into a jelly, which is taken as a sign of "real" collagen.
The marketing leaps from there to claims about hair, skin, joints, gut lining and immunity. That's where the evidence thins. Let's take it step by step.
What's Actually in a Cup
| Measure (per cup, about 240 ml) | Typical range | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Calories | About 30–50 | Very low |
| Protein | About 6–10 g in good products; 1–3 g in some "stocks"; up to 10+ g in strong homemade or café versions | Check the label; range is wide |
| Collagen share of protein | Variable, often cited as 40–80% in product analyses | Depends on bones, joints and simmer time |
| Sodium | Roughly 100–900 mg depending on brand | Many shop-bought versions are salty |
| Other nutrients | Small amounts of minerals | Not a major source of calcium or magnesium |
The Analysis That Tested Real Broths
The most useful independent study is by sports dietitian Rebekah Alcock, Gregory Shaw and Louise Burke at the Australian Institute of Sport and Australian Catholic University, published in the International Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism in 2019. The team analysed amino acids in bone broths made three ways: shop-bought products, café-prepared broths and broths prepared at home to a standard recipe, and compared them with a 20 g dose of collagen supplement of the sort used in research.
- Huge variation. Broths made to non-standard recipes varied enormously in amino acid content, with café-prepared versions highest and some servings containing little protein at all.
- Commercial broths were lower in all amino acids than self-prepared ones when made to a standard recipe.
- Reproducibility was good when recipes were standardised, showing that careful, consistent preparation can give a predictable product, but most broth isn't made that way.
- The conclusion: bone broth is unlikely to provide reliable concentrations of collagen precursors compared with the supplement doses used in collagen research.
Other summaries of the analysis note protein values ranging from well under a gram per mug in some broths to dozens of grams in a very concentrated café serving, which is exactly the problem: you can't tell what you're getting without a label or a lab.
Collagen Isn't a Complete Protein
Protein quality depends on the mix of essential amino acids a food supplies. Collagen and gelatin are rich in glycine, proline and hydroxyproline, but they lack tryptophan altogether and are low in other essential amino acids, including leucine, the key trigger for muscle protein synthesis. By standard protein-quality scoring methods, gelatin rates very poorly as a sole protein source.
That doesn't make collagen "bad". It means it complements, rather than replaces, higher-quality proteins. If most of the protein in a cup of broth is collagen, you're getting a modest amount of protein that's less useful for muscle than the same weight of eggs, dairy, fish or meat. For a bigger picture on leucine and per-meal protein targets, see our protein sources guide.
Collagen Versus Whey for Muscle
A randomised controlled trial by Oikawa and colleagues at McMaster University (American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2020) compared collagen peptides with whey protein in healthy older women, with and without resistance exercise. Whey protein, but not collagen peptides, stimulated muscle protein synthesis acutely and over a longer period of supplementation. The authors concluded that, on a gram-for-gram basis, collagen isn't a good stand-in for whey when the goal is to build or maintain muscle.
That's one trial in one population, but it fits what amino acid profiles predict. If your priority is muscle (as in the older-adult and dieting scenarios we cover elsewhere), build your protein around complete sources and treat broth as a side.
What the Collagen Trials Actually Used
The studies that wellness brands cite generally used measured doses of hydrolysed collagen or gelatin, typically in the range of a few grams up to about 15 g a day, often for weeks or months. One small experiment by Shaw and colleagues (American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2017) found that 15 g of vitamin C-enriched gelatin taken before exercise increased a blood marker of collagen synthesis. That marker is a biochemical signal, not proof of healthier tendons or skin, but it shows how researchers think about dosing.
Compare that with broth: a cup of a typical, standard-recipe product delivers a variable, often small, amount of collagen amino acids, and the Alcock analysis found that none of the standard broths matched a 20 g supplement reference. To reach trial doses from broth alone, you'd need several cups a day of a high-collagen preparation, with a lot of sodium and calories along the way.
The Claims: Joints, Skin and Gut
| Claim | What the evidence says |
|---|---|
| "Supports joints and tendons" | Some trials of hydrolysed collagen supplements suggest modest benefits for joint pain, but we couldn't identify a controlled trial testing bone broth itself for joint outcomes |
| "Improves skin and hair" | Supplement trials report some effects on skin hydration and elasticity, but results come from collagen peptides, not broth, and often from industry-funded studies |
| "Heals the gut" | Largely mechanistic or anecdotal; no good human trials of bone broth for gut healing that we could find |
| "Boosts immunity" | Chicken soup has some laboratory evidence for mild anti-inflammatory effects, but clinical evidence is limited; the warmth, hydration and salt may help you feel better |
| "Rich in minerals" | Contains small amounts; it's not a significant source of calcium, magnesium or phosphorus compared with dairy, fish or vegetables |
Where Broth Genuinely Earns Its Place
None of that makes broth pointless. It has real, if modest, virtues:
- Warm, hydrating and comforting. In cold weather, a hot mug is a pleasant way to meet your fluid goal, as we discuss in our post on winter hydration.
- Low in calories. At around 40 calories a cup, it's an easy savoury sip between meals.
- Gentle when you're ill. It's easy to swallow and digest when your appetite is poor.
- A protein top-up. A decent product adds 6–10 g with minimal calories.
- A base for soups and stews. It adds depth of flavour with minimal calories, helping you cook lower-calorie-density meals. See our piece on soup starters.
- A pleasant ritual. Sometimes the best reason to drink something is that you enjoy it.
Protein Per Calorie: How Broth Compares
This is where broth looks impressive. Using a typical good-quality product (about 9 g of protein for around 40 calories) as an example, its protein density per calorie is high. But the absolute amounts are small, and collagen is a lower-quality protein, so don't read the ratio as a recommendation to replace meals.
| Food (approx. serving) | Calories | Protein (g) | Protein per 100 kcal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good-quality bone broth, 1 cup | 40 | 9 | ≈22 g |
| Chicken breast, 100 g cooked | 165 | 31 | ≈19 g |
| Egg white, 1 large | 17 | 3.6 | ≈21 g |
| Plain non-fat Greek yoghurt, 170 g | 100 | 17 | ≈17 g |
| Whole egg, 1 large | 72 | 6.3 | ≈9 g |
| Firm tofu, 125 g | 110 | 13 | ≈12 g |
| Cooked lentils, 1 cup | 230 | 18 | ≈8 g |
To hit a 25–30 g protein target at a meal, a cup of broth contributes a third at best. Use the protein intake calculator to set your daily number, and think of broth as a supporting player.
How to Make Winter Broth Work Harder
If you like broth, you can turn it into a genuine protein meal with a few additions:
- Egg-drop broth. Whisk two eggs into a hot cup or two of broth for about 12–15 g extra high-quality protein.
- Broth with tofu and miso. Add cubed silken tofu, greens and a spoon of miso for roughly 10–15 g.
- Chicken and vegetable broth bowl. Shred leftover chicken and add noodles or rice for 25 g or more.
- Lentil or bean broth. Cook lentils in the broth for fibre and plant protein.
- Protein-boosted mugs. A spoon of unflavoured whey or milk protein isolate can be whisked into warm (not boiling) broth for an easy 15–20 g, though check for clumping.
These additions bring the complete proteins the broth lacks. For a full soup framework, see our guide to building a satisfying bowl.
A Buying and Cooking Guide
- Read the label. Look for at least 6 g of protein per cup. A product listing under 2 g is closer to seasoned stock.
- Check sodium. Compare brands; choose lower-sodium options or dilute strong ones.
- The gel test. A broth that sets like jelly when chilled has extracted more collagen, which is a rough indicator, not a guarantee of any health benefit.
- Making it at home. Simmer bones (with joints, feet or knuckles for more gelatin) with vegetables, herbs and a little vinegar for roughly 8–24 hours at a gentle heat, then strain. Homemade tends to be cheaper and lower in salt.
- Powdered versions can offer 10–20 g protein per serving, but they're a supplement; the label and the brand's testing matter.
- Check calories and protein in your own recipes with our recipe nutrition calculator.
Who Should Be Careful
- People with high blood pressure, kidney disease or on sodium-restricted diets. Many broths are high in salt.
- People with gout. Meat- and bone-based broths contain purines, which can raise uric acid.
- People with histamine intolerance. Long-simmered broths can be high in histamine and glutamates, and some people react to them.
- Vegetarians and vegans, for obvious reasons; vegetable broths with added tofu or lentils are alternatives.
- Anyone with advanced kidney disease on protein limits should follow their clinician's advice rather than adding protein-rich drinks.
The Bottom Line
Bone broth is a comforting, low-calorie winter drink that can add a modest few grams of protein, and that's a perfectly good reason to enjoy it. It isn't a reliable collagen source, a muscle-builder or a proven joint or gut treatment. The protein is mostly incomplete collagen, amounts vary wildly between products, and standard broths fall well short of the doses used in supplement trials.
So treat it as a supporting player. Sip it for warmth and hydration, check the label, pick a lower-sodium option, and when protein is the goal, top it up with eggs, tofu, chicken or lentils, or put your serious protein elsewhere in the day.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much protein is in bone broth?
A good-quality cup typically has 6–10 g, but published analyses show enormous variation, from under 1 g to over 10 g per serving, so check the label.
Is bone broth a complete protein?
No. The protein is largely collagen or gelatin, which lacks tryptophan and is low in several essential amino acids, so it's not a complete protein.
Does bone broth build muscle?
Not effectively on its own. In a randomised trial in older women, whey protein stimulated muscle protein synthesis but collagen peptides did not. Use complete proteins like eggs, dairy, fish, meat or soy for muscle.
Is bone broth good for joints and skin?
Some trials of hydrolysed collagen supplements suggest modest benefits, but we found no controlled trial of bone broth itself, and standard broths provide much less collagen than supplement doses.
Is bone broth better than collagen powder?
For collagen dose, supplements are more reliable. A 2019 analysis found broths made to a standard recipe contained less of the collagen amino acids than a 20 g collagen supplement, with shop-bought broth lower still.
How many calories are in bone broth?
About 30–50 calories per cup for most plain versions.
Can I drink bone broth every day?
Most healthy adults can, if the sodium fits their diet. People with high blood pressure, kidney disease, gout or histamine intolerance should check with a clinician.
References & Sources
- Alcock, R. D., Shaw, G. C. & Burke, L. M. (2019). Bone broth unlikely to provide reliable concentrations of collagen precursors compared with supplemental sources of collagen used in collagen research. International Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism, 29(3), 265–272.
- Alcock, R. D., Shaw, G. C., Tee, N. & Burke, L. M. (2019). Plasma amino acid concentrations after the ingestion of dairy and collagen proteins, in healthy active males. Frontiers in Nutrition, 6, 163.
- Oikawa, S. Y. et al. (2020). Whey protein but not collagen peptides stimulate acute and longer-term muscle protein synthesis with and without resistance exercise in healthy older women: a randomized controlled trial. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 111(3), 708–718.
- Shaw, G. et al. (2017). Vitamin C-enriched gelatin supplementation before intermittent activity augments collagen synthesis. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 105(1), 136–143.
- Hsu, D. J., Lee, C. W., Tsai, W. C. & Chien, Y. C. (2017). Essential and toxic metals in animal bone broths. Food & Nutrition Research, 61(1), 1347480.
- MacrosMeasure (2026). Free Protein Intake Calculator.
- MacrosMeasure (2026). Free Recipe Nutrition Calculator.
Calculate your own numbers — free.
18 science-backed calculators covering everything in this article and more.
